I know I reviewed this one before but I have more to say. I saw this movie so many times using up my movies per week that I formed all kinds of opinions that didn't show up in the original watch.
The first thing is that this is Kate Hudson's movie. I have to wonder how it would have gone if the original Claire Sardina wasn't still alive. They really gave her the kid glove treatment in the script and I have to ask myself if that's because they had to make her look good. If not the publicity wouldn't have been nearly as sweet and wholesome.
Each time I watched this thing I tried to focus on something different. I kind of had to do that. One thing that I really liked each time was the set design. Yup. I looked at that. It was very much a 1980s lower middle class midwestern house. And oddly enough that was nearly enough for the studio to cancel it or at least try to demand changes.
The interior of the house is brown. It's so brown. There's brown paneling. There's brown furniture. There's brown wall accessories. There's brown carpeting. For those of us who grew up at that time it's comforting. It's home. There were granny square afghans on the couch and bed. There were brass decorations on the walls. The back of the stove held the can of Pam and some spices. The tables were cluttered with things that didn't fit into the cabinets. The cabinets were a mess. It was a lived in house.
I have to wonder how the stars felt about the set. It might have been claustrophobic. Hugh lived in Australia with a larger family and I don't think they had the same decorative style. Kate is from a famous family and you know they have big houses. The rooms are the correct proportions for the lives of the characters. If you didn't grow up in these kinds of spaces it can feel weird. It also means they had to keep the blocking to a minimum since there just wasn't room to move around much.
I'm still glad Hugh didn't try for a local accent and went with generic American. There's a few times when his pronunciation was just wrong and when they used vernacular in place of an accent so that stood out to a native. I doubt that outside of the region people noticed but here? People notice. Kate's accent was more northwestern than Milwaukee but it was light enough to work. We also don't know where she grew up so it could have been "her" natural accent anyway. Almost everyone else had American neutral accents.
Watching it a few times you can really see how they messed with how time passed. I think the original duo was active for seventeen years before it ended and here they compressed it into two and a half hours. I have a feeling a lot of that was because of the kids. Aging kids is difficult and it would have made them either irrelevant to the story or taken up more as they matured. Keeping them as-is was a wise decision, as was squeezing things down into an indetermined but shorter timeframe. Instead of pinning it to a timeline they pinned it to defining events. Same result, different methods.
Showing them as a duo act didn't really happen until the final show of the movie. They played together, they cuddled on stage, they shared the songs. But Kate/Claire didn't get out from behind the keyboard until the last show. That change was actually kind of jarring. Until then it was Hugh/Mike up front and her backing him or singing her parts from the back. Either they should have brought her forward more in the shows ongoing or left her in the back for the big show. Regardless it's something that's noticeable on repeated viewings.
Other things I noticed I only noticed because I read a version of the screenplay. I can see where parts were filmed but the rest of the plot was left behind. I agree with what they cut, don't get me wrong. I think it made for a better movie. It just leaves these odd little things that don't go anywhere and don't have any reference. Little things but the whole movie is made of little things.
I haven't watched it since it left the theaters. I could, but I haven't. I watched it too many times in close succession to watch it again for a while. I want some time where I can try to let it fade and I can rediscover things and/or not get annoyed at things. That's a problem with repeated watching - you see stuff that you'd miss on a single viewing.
I think Kate should have gotten the Golden Globe for her performance. As she said, when the hot rollers came out she became Claire. I do admit that I also liked that she gained weight to soften up for the role. I think she looks better that way than she does now. It's not just midwestern bias. It's that she just looks better with some fat under her skin. Thin is not always better.
I will probably be seeing this again in the near future. My movie snob friend has a big TV and twenty six speaker sound bar but not the streaming service to see the movie. I have the service so I'll probably be going over to watch it on his home theater. I have it on my media server, of course, but that's not an option for him for two reasons. One is that he's adamantly against how I populate my media server. The other is that the one on streaming will be of higher resolution and that matters for his setup. I will admit I've been curious to see what he's done.
I kinda wonder how Hugh felt about slipping into the role of a lower middle-class middle-aged Midwesterner or if it was just another part for him. He's normally cast in much larger than life roles so something this small may have been different for him.